I used to like Christian Bale. I used to think he was a good actor. ‘Terminator Salvation’ has fixed that. It is partially because he went off on his DP, and partially because he has never risen above his source material.
One thing that makes an actor great is that even when they star in a bad film (it happens to everyone), they still manage to pull a strong, or at least humorous, performance. ‘Miss Congeniality’ is a horrible movie, but Michael Caine almost saves it. Kate Winslet, probably the best working actress today (other than Meryl) made ‘The Holiday’ a little more bearable. There are plenty of examples out there. Has Christian Bale ever done that? Nah.
‘American Psycho’ was a decent movie for the first 2/3s, but then, in an attempt to leave the film up to interpretation, does not make sense any way you want to think about it. Not only that, but Bale was campy and not the way Patrick Bateman should have been. He may look exactly how Patrick Bateman would look, but he didn’t pull it off. Is it his fault that the movie was bad? Certainly not. But did he salvage anything for himself? No.
Skip to ‘Equilibrium,’ which, again, was decent until the end. Bale played the part of a strong, stoic alpha male, but that’s not anything new. That seems to be the only part he can play. Give us some variety!
‘3:10 to Yuma’ was a strong Western, but not because of him. Again, anyone could have played his part and done it just as well. Russell Crowe carried that movie.
‘Batman Begins’ was a great movie, but that’s because Chris Nolan wrote and directed a great script. Bale is a good Batman, but that’s because all Batman has to do is be a hard-ass. ‘The Dark Knight’ was much worse than ‘Batman Begins’ (though still good), and here we see even less diversity from Bruce Wayne and he is again heavily overshadowed by the villains.
‘The Prestige’ is a great film, but again, because the source material was good. Any actor could have played his part. He plays the stoic magician (half of the time) who only cares about his magic. It looks like it hurts to smile or show emotion. Also, easily upstaged by Michael Caine and Hugh Jackman.
And, of course, ‘Terminator Salvation,’ which is complete trash across the board. Bad plot, bad script, bad action, bad acting. Maybe Christian Bale was convincing as an action star in Batman, but here it falls flat. I would’ve been more entertained watching Kermit fight Skynet.