Oh, Adaptation., how I love and loathe thee.
This is a great movie. As a whole it is good, and as a study it is outstanding. But there are flaws I cannot overlook on my third or fourth viewing.
However, one of those flaws is definitely not the story seminar. Charlie Kaufman’s brother Donald recommends that he attend a story seminar. At this point Charlie has written some great material, including ‘Being John Malkovich’, but he is stuck, so he goes. The seminar is led by Bob McKee, played by the great Brian Cox (who is consistently underrated as a great actor).
Now, as with all of the great film clips I post, the scene will be much more effective if you have seen the whole movie. But let me tell my fellow artists, ‘Adaptation.’ is about writing, and not only this clip, but the whole film, can be a lesson. Notice how when McKee says, “God help you if you use voice-over in your work, my friends. God hep you. That’s flaccid, sloppy writing. Any idiot can write voice-over in narration to explain the thought of a character,” the voice-over in the movie itself (Adaptation.) stops completely. It is totally self-aware, and for that reason, it is both smarter than 90% of the films ever made and worth a watch by every person who enjoys quality cinema.
And how about when Brian Cox tells off Nic Cage in one of the best condescending monologues of all time?
Many people have seen Charlie Kaufman’s work. ‘Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind’ is a popular favorite. That is a good film. But to really get an experience, one should either watch ‘Being John Malkovich’ or ‘Adaptation.’. Both are completely excellent and both should be considered required viewing.