Editor’s note: Taken from the old blog and posted here. Anachronisms removed.
First, let me say that this year was not as strong as last year (2007). Last year I had trouble just picking ten, and while I’ve seen plenty of movies this year, few have had a lasting impact, which is somewhat required of all great movies. A movie has not done its job unless you’re still pondering about it 24 hours later. This year, lots of films need to be fired. These are the ones that will last.
1. WALL-E
I struggle with this choice, because choosing an animated film as my number one of the year seems taboo. Well, rules be damned, this is a spectacular film. Pixar has achieved such a significant level of storytelling that they scarcely even need dialogue anymore. WALL-E, both the robot himself and the film, possess an overwhelming compassion. WALL-E, with more determination than any robot has ever had before him, begins by pursuing his love for EVE, and ends up saving humanity. At first he tries to recover the plant to impress EVE, but along the way, somewhere, he realizes his purpose. Similarly, EVE transforms from a simple one-track robot to a real character, capable of more emotion than most characters in most other films. For these reasons, along with perfect animation, a great soundtrack, and a high ‘cute’ factor, WALL-E is the best film of the year.
2. Slumdog Millionaire
In my ‘review’ I copped out, saying that to reveal any plot details at all would dishonor the film and ruin the experience. I stand by that. This is not a film that is watched, but a story that is experienced. There is no better reason to go to the movies this year than to see this film. We shall discuss it later.
3. Revolutionary Road
Unlike Slumdog Millionaire, this is not a film for everyone. Revolutionary Road is a story likely to hit emotional chords with specific viewers because its characters have big dreams and even bigger falls. The truth about life is that not everyone finds their happy ending or meets their one true love — some people end up living in the suburbs and slowly die little by little every day. I have a feeling this is one of those films that will be praised ten years from now, but until then, be passed off as mediocre. Trust me, it is a great treasure.
Editor’s note: Revolutionary Road is written about in details as a Movie to Study
4. The Wrestler
Mickey Rourke, as The Ram, struggles deeply with his identity, his past, and his addictions. What is so touching in this story of one man’s life is not the actual wrestling, but how far his life has gone past its prime and how determined he is to make it right, even after he blows it one time after the other.
5. In Bruges
I recently watched this again, and am thrilled that the film has a screenplay nod for the Oscars. Sure, the politically incorrect humor is funny, but behind the vulgar comedy is a fine layer of weaving between the characters and their actions that makes the film work. Each viewing leads to the picking up of something new, for instance, when Ken drops the coins from the top of the tower toward the end, he doesn’t just happen to have coins (like most people), but they are the coins the clerk would not take way earlier in the film. Excellent.
6. Gran Torino
Can we all agree on something? Clint Eastwood is The Man. Not only is he one of the best actors to ever live, but he has directed many GREAT films — not ‘good’ films, but great ones. Just counting recent years, we have: Million Dollar Baby, Letter From Iwo Jima, Mystic River, and now Gran Torino. Dealing with aggressive racial issues (sort of like In Bruges, but in its own way), Gran Torino is a spectacular film about acceptance, forgiveness, vengeance, and doing the right thing. No matter what you read, it will still not be what you expect, but you will enjoy every minute of it.
7. Iron Man
Yes, there is a superhero movie on this list. No, it is not the overrated Dark Knight. Iron Man is such a success because — and this is fundamental to all stories — we care about the protagonist, the man, the hero. Tony Stark, while kind of a jerk, makes us laugh, and laughter is the way to the heart, right? I think that’s a proverb. This is a superhero film done extremely right, and the best since Spidey 2.
8. Rachel Getting Married
Seeming strangely like a documentary, this film is a treasure. It uses a unique pacing style to include the audience as a member of the family, and by the end we still don’t completely understand the dysfunction, but we appreciate it. Anne Hathaway has not been better, but the whole cast is perfect in this little film about what chunks of our past belong to us, which chunks are community canon fodder, and why some people can’t stop being selfish, just for one day. But why should they have to?
9. Religulous
Bill Maher makes fun of every religion, pointing out all of the contradictions and implausible theories behind creationism, the virgin Mary, Jesus, etc. Not perfect, but very funny.
10. Milk
A film that is moving, because Harvey Milk was not just fighting for gay rights, but for the rights and equality of all peoples. He was beaten election after election, but through perseverance, determination, and a little luck, he succeeded. Again, not a perfect movie, but one that everyone could benefit from seeing.
And that is it for 2008. Intentionally left off because they are undeserving of any ‘best’ list, or any ‘Best Picture’ nomination: The Curious Case of Benjamin Button, Frost/Nixon, The Dark Knight, The Reader.
The New Calamity 